What is Logic??

canna · Post time 31-7-2007 01:18 AM

Logic is the art of convincing us of some truth.

True-X · Post time 31-7-2007 12:13 PM

LOGIC... sumthing comes with purpose and reason.. why, when ,how...

thamrong · Post time 31-7-2007 05:51 PM

Originally posted by Agul at 31-7-2007 12:29 AM

My professor never tells me this. maybe he's too busy making money...

!דרישת שלום

redsinner · Post time 31-7-2007 10:31 PM

thank you!

just finished reading on Husserl and his 'phenomenology'....
that is how i got to that scientific bit. he really had this scienticism going on. pening otak aku sbnrnyerr....

thamrong · Post time 31-7-2007 10:57 PM

Originally posted by redsinner at 31-7-2007 10:31 PM
thank you!

just finished reading on Husserl and his 'phenomenology'....
that is how i got to that scientific bit. he really had this scienticism going on. pening otak aku sbnrnyerr....

In philosophy, the topic under Phenomenology and Existentialism by Husserl, Heidegger, Sartre and Camus are very difficult to understand. My wife told me to burn the books before I go crazy

These people must be from different planet. I am happy that you try to read them.

Agul · Post time 31-7-2007 11:47 PM

[quote]Originally posted by thamrong at 31-7-2007 05:51 PM

!דרישת שלום

Mansairaku · Post time 1-8-2007 01:19 AM

Originally posted by redsinner at 29-7-2007 03:38 PM
simply can i say logic = rationale?

if we have a set of ideas and then it is being proved scientifically or physically, can it be rationale?
notions being materialised into a theory?

" ....scientifically or physically" ... an interesting quote

meanwhile,
an interesting debate is happening between anime fans regarding the following matter:

H1 and H2 are twins
H1 = has a daughter
H2 = has a son

In most cultures, it is perfectly alright to marry cousins ..including Asia, Europe etc....except for US.
Their argument: twins have the same DNA, therefore if the cousins are marrying each other, they are actually marrying their siblings.
However, opposing fans counter-argued that if the same context is being used, then will it be alright for H1 to bed H2's wife since they practically have the same DNA?

Err...what is logic again?

makes me sometimes wonder if "logic", "science" or "physics" are mere human interpretation of majority-accepted norm....
there should be more (spiritually? as well?) than material proofs?
and a long long time ago ...people actually believed that the world was flat ....

thamrong · Post time 1-8-2007 05:58 PM

Originally posted by Agul at 31-7-2007 11:47 PM

I can't read that...

It's in Hebrew! Shalom! Greetings! Peace!

thamrong · Post time 1-8-2007 09:15 PM

Exercise your mind. find out how to construct and communicate philosophical arguements. Not for dumbo

Agul · Post time 1-8-2007 11:37 PM

Maluhia!

redsinner · Post time 3-8-2007 11:35 AM

yeah...
i guess i can grasp the idea of Phenomenology by Husserl..then, next text was What is metaphysics by Heidegger...
Heidegger questioned "What is Being and being?"
he asked how 'beings' define existence on earth. what is earth or world that we pertaining to the question....
am reading it....tgh giler....

itu belum part 'beings' being a man lagi... waaaaaaaaaa

redsinner · Post time 3-8-2007 11:42 AM

like Husserl pointed out in Scientism, does a scientific analysis be valid for prove?
because it is bizarre that scientific can be as abstract and subjective as other art value itself.
because in order for scientists to prove scientifically, they had to try every possible method that might be perceived as abstract and subjective to get the results.

thamrong · Post time 4-8-2007 08:51 PM

The world was a screwed up place. its chaotic and disorderly. I mean the human thinking. Aristotle thought us things can be put in a proper orderly manner. He formulated the thinking methodology through deduction that influence mathematics, physical science, language, justice and law.

ajinomotonosuga · Post time 5-8-2007 07:33 AM

Wei Loon is a chinese. Many chinese work hard and play less.
Wei Loon works hard and play less.

This is Logic. But not necessarily true. To the least it gives the reader sort of perception about something. The argument is based upon 'words'. Logic is from the latin word Logo means word. U build something with words. Just like a kids build a crane with Lego's block. So logic is the block of words.

when we said it is logical, we dont mean about the truth of what we said but simply the 'sensibility' of the story. IT NEEDS FURTHER analytical but i prefer to call it DISCERNMENT.

What is the sum of 12 plus 3?
some might say 15. some might say 3.

the second answer is LOGIC too if one is using 24 hours format .ie. 1500 hundreds hour that is 3 o'clock.(u get this thru discernment, i.e. u need further THINKING)

when i was at form five, my maths teaches loved to do a show. He will raise his point finger and ask 'what is this'?

if we told him that is a finger he answered it Salah, this is One. Later on if we answered it is ALIF, he said Salah, this is a finger. And on and on. That is what happened when WE PLAY WITH WORDS i.e. logo , the blocks of words.