CariDotMy

 Forgot password?
 Register

ADVERTISEMENT

12Next
Return to list New
View: 7412|Reply: 32

Social experiment : Gadis bertudung makan depan khalayak ramai... Perlu ke tak

 Close [Copy link]
Post time 27-6-2016 11:45 AM | Show all posts |Read mode
Harassed for being seen eating during Ramadan
Social media user Mrym Lee tells of verbal abuse and public persecution while trying to make a protest against moral and religious policing.






PETALING JAYA: A Muslim woman who is an activist has taken issue with the harassment, verbal abuse and public persecution that goes with moral and religious policing of Muslims in Malaysia.
The woman, who goes by the name ‘Mrym Lee’ on Facebook and Twitter,has ignited a debate on the issue of moral policing in the country.
In a recent posting, she wrote about how she and a friend were harassed in public when they both decided to make a protest against moral and religious policing by deliberately eating and drinking in public during Ramadan, while visibly being a Muslim in hijab.
On one occasion, a restaurant manager in a Kuala Lumpur shopping mall questioned whether she was a Malay and Muslim, and why she was not fasting.
She said that eating and drinking were not against the law, only for the manager to respond to her by saying she was “damaging” the image of Islam.
“I then went to him, explaining how he’s been rude to me as a customer, and he explained that religious authorities could raid the restaurant and mete out penalties for serving Muslims during Ramadan.”
Five minutes later, a Malay Muslim customer at the restaurant with his family came to her table to question her right to eat in public, accusing her of not respecting those who were fasting. He, too, accused her of not respecting Islam.
Mrym Lee said such religious policing of other people’s personal beliefs and rituals was rife and backwards mentality was worrying.
“Get your priorities straight. Go punish our corrupt politicians and fix our messed-up policies. Leave the practice of faiths to the individual, empower each other in society to do good, only then we’ll see productive progress,” she wrote.
Her accounts and subsequent polls on her Twitter account have drawn mixed views. Some commenters supported her, saying she was right to stand up for her rights. Others said that while she was within her rights to eat in public when not fasting, it was disrespectful to do so in front of others, with one commenter saying that eating in front of fasting children made it hard for the children to keep up with their fasting.
Some commenters chastised her and questioned her lack of common sense.
Mrym ran two polls, one asking Muslims whether they ate or drank in public during Ramadan and another on whether they felt it was wrong to do so.
Some 58 per cent of 835 respondents said they did not eat or drink in public out of respect of other Muslims, while 63 per cent of 701 respondents said it was not wrong for Muslims to eat or drink in public during Ramadan.



Single Polls, Total 60 Users voted
78.33% (47)
15.00% (9)
6.67% (4)
Your User group have no permission to vote
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


 Author| Post time 27-6-2016 11:46 AM | Show all posts

Public eating ‘experiment’ provocative, says Islamic group

PETALING JAYA: Even with legitimate reasons for not fasting during Ramadan, no Muslim should try to provoke their fellow Muslims who are fasting.

“If you’re permitted to eat, what’s wrong with eating in your room? Why do you have to do it in public?” questioned Islamic Renaissance Front (IRF) Chairman Dr Ahmad Farouk Musa.

He was referring to Mrym Lee, a local Muslim woman, who in a recent protest against moral and religious policing, deliberately ate and drank in public during Ramadan, while wearing the hijab.

Farouk said though he was also against authorities conducting moral and religious policing on people, the alleged “social experiment” conducted by Mrym was “unnecessary and unethical”.

“We should not condone moral and religious policing, but at the same time, the social experiment was unnecessary and a little too vexatious.”

Mrym had taken to social media, writing about her experiences in carrying out the protest, as well as how she and a friend had been harassed in public.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 11:48 AM | Show all posts
dah ada la thread ni kat bod  Kongsi Viral
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 11:50 AM | Show all posts
Berani mati hakak ni tauu!
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 11:56 AM | Show all posts
Bodoh piang! Tu je aku nak kata...
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 11:59 AM | Show all posts
ade masalah ape kalau dia nak makan pun? takkan tengok orang makan dah merana sangat perut tu....macam baru mula berpuasa pulak....
Reply

Use magic Report

Follow Us
Post time 27-6-2016 12:01 PM | Show all posts
Loxlaxman replied at 27-6-2016 11:56 AM
Bodoh piang! Tu je aku nak kata...

Dia jahil yg tak boleh/ mahu belajar. Tolonglah jgn beri dia promosi percuma...
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:01 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Bab toleransi beragama ni ummah semenanjung kena belajar dengan sabah sarawak dan indonesia. Depa lg bagus dr orang semenanjung.
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 27-6-2016 12:09 PM | Show all posts
budak ni mereng ke hapa?

what is she trying to prove?
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:11 PM | Show all posts
kalau statement ini dibuat oleh orang lain, mungkin aku ada banyak point untuk bercakap
tapi sebab yang buat ni Maryam Lee ratu attention seeker, I'm shutting my mouth
selayaknya kau dek
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:15 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Entah..aku nk kondem psal apa. Generally..budak ni cuba mendptkan jwpn bgi sesuatu isu yg bagi dia tk relevan. Sesuatu yg bagus..tp malaysia mindset malaysian mudah dibaca. Biarlah makpak dia ajar cara yg betul..kita pon didkla anak2 sndiri agar tidak teraba2 didlm terang.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:16 PM | Show all posts
mungkin dia tk tau yg dlm perkara2 beragama ni ada juga adab2 yg perlu diikuti.... klu tk, hari2 kau akan maki org yg buat benda haram..tp sb kita ada adab, lain pulalah cara nya utk menegur golongan begini.. sb itu berdakwahitu kena ada adab nya...


dlm hal buadak ni..mungkin dia tak tau sb terlupa..@ mungkin dia tk diajar perkara2 adab ni....


dgn kata lain... KURANG AJAR la tu....
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:19 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
Sebulan je.pun..hormatilah bulan puasa dan org yg berpuasa..nk mkn x salah..cr la port yg sesuai..
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:24 PM | Show all posts
aku dengar kat radio, ustaz cakap, walaupun anda ada keuzuran, tak bermakna anda boleh makan terang2..

hormatilah bulan yang suci ini.. kalau lapar sangat makan la dekat bilik tertutup.. walaupun orang yang tengok sikit pun tak terkesan..

itu la bawak2 la dengar radio ikim.. ini asik dok dengar radio era yang gelak terbahak2 sampai gelap hati dek banyak sangat ketawa

btw tempat kerja aku yang minoriti muslim, majority expats from uk pun dorang paham makan sesama dorang je.. and siap cakap sorry kalau ada coffee breath ke ape ke..
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:24 PM | Show all posts
nk mkan pun mkn lah..
sbb semua org tahu ada masa nya prempuan x boleh puasa
cari lah tempat2 yg sesuai..bukan dikhalayak umum...mkan lah byk mana pun..
bukan sbb org yg puasa kebulur sgt x boleh tengok org lain makan
cuma hormatilah org yg berpuasa..
x rugi apa2 pun kan..
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:25 PM | Show all posts
X perlu pon....
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 27-6-2016 12:29 PM | Show all posts
Perlu ada sifat hormat menghormati
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:37 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
makan je lah kat mana pun tapi tak perlu la tempat open..
kalau nak makan kat kedai sangat cari la tempat tersorok sikit..
org faham..
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:50 PM | Show all posts
..sebagai sorang yang berpuasa, sepatutnya lagi suka orang makan depan dia, sebab lagi banyak godaan lagi besar pahala nya ... yang bising2 orang makan bulan puasa tu dasar orang2 tak beriman ...
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 27-6-2016 12:59 PM From the mobile phone | Show all posts
ai malu kalau org tahu period..so makan sembunyi2...

Tapi minah attention seeker ni sengaja je kan nak provoke...biasalah budak tak matang...dan2 lagi kait dengan kerajaan korup bagai kan...
Reply

Use magic Report

12Next
Return to list New
You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register

Points Rules

 

ADVERTISEMENT



 

ADVERTISEMENT


 


ADVERTISEMENT
Follow Us

ADVERTISEMENT


Mobile|Archiver|Mobile*default|About Us|CariDotMy

28-11-2024 01:48 AM GMT+8 , Processed in 0.063823 second(s), 34 queries , Gzip On, Redis On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

Copyright © 2001-2021, Tencent Cloud.

Quick Reply To Top Return to the list