Marina: There’s art and there’s sleaze - bogel atas nama seni adalah terpuji

cecari

There’s art and there’s sleaze                                        Musings
By Marina Mahathir

                                                                                                                                   
  
Kuala Lumpur may not be Paris, and we may not yet be ready for fashion photographer Helmut Newton’s nudes, but to ban ballet seems a very unsophisticated thing to do.
I WAS in Paris recently and with some free time one Sunday afternoon, I decided to see an exhibition at the Grand Palais, one of the city’s many museums.
My husband had suggested I go and see the retrospective of the work of the famous fashion photographer Helmut Newton who died in 2004.
Although Newton’s job was to showcase the designs of fashion designers like Yves St Laurent, he had a very particular vision of how he presented the clothes.
Invariably, his models are beautiful, strong, even athletic, women. Not for him any coy poses, his photos show women in almost confrontational stances.
That cold spring afternoon the line to see the Newton show snaked down the street.
Young and old, Parisians and tourists shivered for up to two hours to hand over €11 (RM44) for entry to the exhibition.
Inside, they were met with a huge exhibition, dozens of photos throughout his long career as well as a video made by his wife, June.
They were also greeted with literally huge works.
Gigantic photos lined the walls of some of the exhibition rooms, almost all of them of nude women, full frontal, standing tall and proud.
Unflinching and powerful, the exhibit has generated some debate as to whether Newton was a misogynist or a feminist.
I am inclined, having viewed the entire exhibition, to think he was the latter, albeit an unconscious one.
As I toured the exhibition, I watched the crowd as much as I looked at the photographs.
People treated the show with the same respect as they would an exhibition of the Old Masters.
They knew this was art and the work of a great photographer.
They paid good money to view this.
Confronted with the nudes, nobody sniggered or threw up their hands in horror.
Nobody ran out of the room screaming in moral indignation.
I have read no reports of anyone being inspired to rape anyone after being exposed to Newton’s work. There were no protests outside the museum.
There could be several explanations for the calm Parisian reaction to Newton.
Some might say that they are so morally degenerate that they have become immune to the sight of such full frontal nudity.
On the other hand, we can also say that the French are such mature and sophisticated people that they know when something is art and, therefore, worthy of respect, and when something is sleazy and pornographic and, therefore, is not.
Those who may disapprove always have the option of saving their money and staying home.
I flew home from the cold weather in Paris to the heat of home to find myself transported to another world, not just meteorologically.
While thousands of Parisians queued to view Newton’s exhibition, back home, a troupe of classical ballet dancers, fully dressed ones, were banned from performing in Malaysia to a much smaller but also paying audience.
Kuala Lumpur may not be Paris, and we may not yet be ready for Newton’s nudes.
After all, some years ago, an exhibition of Ferdinand Botero’s fat nude sculptures was axed in case some of us got too excited by the sight of giant breasts and bums.
But still, to ban ballet seems a very unsophisticated thing to do.
After all we have dozens of little girls dressing up in tutus for their ballet lessons every weekend.
I myself did ballet as a tiny tot. I don’t think my parents were setting me up for a life of immorality when they sent me to ballet class.
But the point is really this: why should the authorities decide for us what or who we should or should not see?
Especially when we are talking about paying money to attend such shows.
By that alone, the audience is limited and, therefore, whatever alleged “immoral” impact our authorities imagine would naturally be severely curtailed.
Nobody is being forced to watch anything.
Even though the ban has subsequently been lifted, the damage has already been done.
Is it too much to ask that there be a stop to this nonsense?
We are fast gaining a reputation as a place that no artiste wants to come to. But more importantly, why should people who know nothing censor culture and the arts?
In a country where a movie about a rapist is celebrated, why do we censor dance performances, women singers and men who are simply not macho?
Which is more harmful?
Or are even our arts censors keeping one eye on the elections, and somehow imagine that ballet would be an issue we should vote on?

cecari

Marina ni patut diharamkan bersuara di malaysia.. pandangan dan pemikiran yg boleh merosakkan masyarakat

dino

mcm ade pendpt kata negara yg amalkan seks bebas... kurang jenayah rogol.... no need merogol maaa.... seks didapati ngan mudah.... wpun hidup sama lebel ngan haiwan....
marina ni berpandangan pikiran rakyat msia ni kena canggih manggih n terbuka melampau2....
takleh sekat org yg byr duit nak tgk ballet gituh.... nak jdkan msia btul2 sekular nmpknya....

baghal_bortuqal

We lurv vogeh!!!

alahai

We lurv vogeh!!!
baghal_bortuqal Post at 11-4-2012 10:41

   yeahhhh!!!!!!! sokom...

cecari

and we may not yet be ready for fashion photographer Helmut Newton’s nudes

kita hanya masih tidak bersedia saja. kata dia la. maknanya dia menghalalkan menda yg haram?

baghal_bortuqal

Pulau ppl sunggoh

unhas

liberal, biasa la tu. kat sini pun banyak.......

unhas

liberal, biasa la tu. kat sini pun banyak.......

zettyzara

adehhhh... soh marina catwalk vogel lu la... smbil background lagu i'm too sexy.... baru la arts sangat!!

zettyzara

xpon soh die wat pole dance vogel ngn back ground lg tu gak.... fuyoooo lg artssssss!!

AHMADVW

hahaaa no wonderlh pmikiran dia ni pelik bogel kehulu khilr last2 dia sendiri yg xnk bugil

atira

sokom marina

hzln

Mampu jaga pandangan sendiri saja, itu pun kadang2 mampu kadang2 terbabas kadang2 sengaja membabaskan diri :lol:
Namun untuk impose nilai yg kita pegang kpd orang...it's just not me.

Yg halal tetap halal yg haram tetap haram. Paling2 minima kita memperakui itu, sama ada benar2 kita amalkan atau tidak, itu sudah masuk level ke-2, kalau level 1 pun dah kita nyahkan, makanya tanya diri sendiri sajalah, islam kita ini di mana?

Jika yg menulis ini bukan islam, aku blh pejam sebelah mata saja buat2 tak nampak, tapi sebab yg menulis ini org islam, mahu tak mahu aku kena berkata sesuatu.

Moga hati kita sentiasa didorong utk berada di landasan yg betul. Amin.


(posted by mobile)