CariDotMy

 Forgot password?
 Register

ADVERTISEMENT

Author: dauswq

[KBS]Good Doctor - Moon Chae Won,Joo Won

[Copy link]
Post time 11-10-2013 02:46 PM | Show all posts
kakJAHku posted on 10-10-2013 11:44 PM
teater peter pan memang x bleh blah..part mermaid tu memg epic giler

kan... hahaha.. rajin btol doktor2 nye..
ade ke hosp real wt gitu?
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 11-10-2013 02:51 PM | Show all posts
habis pon tgk cite ni..
waaaa.. sukaa sukaaa ending die..

sweet sgt moon2 couple ni..













Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 11-10-2013 02:52 PM | Show all posts
bakal merindui semua cast dlm ni..





crdt : tumblr





Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 11-10-2013 06:24 PM | Show all posts
p.timur3831 posted on 11-10-2013 11:53 AM
lol..yg saya maksudkn tu ending film park ki kwang brlakon tu secretly greatly....awk dh bgth ...

Aigooo....sori dah terbagi spoiler pulak...xpe, weekend ni tengok yer...soriiiii
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 11-10-2013 06:27 PM | Show all posts
YoonArang posted on 11-10-2013 02:52 PM
bakal merindui semua cast dlm ni..

Iols pun akan rindu cite good doctor btw, comel pulak tgk Dr. Han
Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 13-10-2013 01:48 AM | Show all posts

Good Doctor


Rating Keseluruhan Drama:  (7.6+9.2+7.2+4+2.5 =7.63/10)

1. Cerita  (7.6/10)

Btw aku agak kecewa sket ngan keseluruhan jln cerita...agak low pacing boleh buatkan tak fokus , kadang2 stop kejap cerita utk buat menda lain...

DARI SEGI PLOT..
first epi (intro) mmg awesome tp bile masuk 2nd epi & seterusnya plot cerita mcm stagnant...graph mendatar
wlpn ade pelbagai kes2 medical, tp tak de pun yg compelling kecuali kes budak penyanyi nak bunuh diri tu...
nak di compare ngan drama jepun iryu , even ngan drama new heart (lakonan ji sung, rahmat mega) pun leh nampak pacing agak mendebarkan hati...tp tak drama ni tak rasa debaran tu even kes in hye yg last tu, mcm dh expect dia tak mati...

kesah plot jahat dibuat pun kurang sgt menjadi ..tak rase "tense"...settle last2 mcm tak de ape2 sgt yg berlaku..
patutnya boleh dipolishkan 'kesah plot jahat' ni supaya menjadikan hospital betul2 menghadapi krisis
cthnya: salahsorg rkn ahli medical terdekat kena buang kerja sbb tak mampu byr gaji, dan prof dong wan cuba buat sedaya upaya tuk tarik balik dia masuk dlm hospital...

i praise one thing about the plot...
cerita tak langgar lari ngan goalnya utk mendidik msyrkt ttg autism..
ditunjukkan si on camne pada mulanya dia tidak diterima ramai, kemudian dia boleh blend-in ngan kwn2 dia, malah diberi peluang utk operate patients sendiri...

i also praise comical sense yg cuba diterapkan..
kecomelan watak autism si on, nurse laki yg gemuk , perangai marah2 yoo seo tp at the same time hv warm personality, keseriusan watak kim dong han sedikit sbyk menutup kebosanan cerita ni...

DARI SEGI GOAL...
fulfilled...org autisim pun ade hak utk tunjukkan mereka juga punyai 'dream' yg sama...
pada mulanya si on punyai difficulties utk fulfill his dream tp hasil skongan org tercinta & rkn2 medical telah byk bantu dia cope with his problem...
malah dr kelebihan sbg pakar diagnosis terhebat & boleh bayangkan 3d dr luaran, beliau sudah boleh gunakan "tangan" utk operate patient sendiri...


Memorial scenes:
1. Si On bagi surprise kissing maut kpd yoon seo semasa gath yoon seo ngan kwn2 sekerja
2. Si On bawa bunga nak propose kat yoon seo tapi sbb takut sgt, dia tak jadi buat
3. Patient pertama yg dioperate oleh cha yo seo mati...

I NOTICE ONE THING...
lagu2 penyanyi malaysia zee avi  byk dimainkan dlm drama ni...



2. Keberkesanan Lakonan (9.2/10)

(Meter:  WORST---MEDIOCRE---BELOW AVERAGE---AVERAGE---FAIR---SUPERIOR---OUTSTANDING)

Moon Jo Won
Pada pendapat aku, lakonan Moon Jo Won adalah OUTSTANDING...natural acting, wtk autism yg dibawa tidak annoying, malah nampak sangat cute...boleh sisi karakternya spt yg dibawa oleh shah rukh khan dlm my name khan...he is a such natural talented actor
he will be nominated in Best Actor category

Moon Chae Won

tak der sape leh pertingkai lakonan MCW...but naper yek aku tak rase puas ngan lakonannya? sbb cerita sendu ke?
bg aku, lakonan chae won dlm cerita ni tak sehebat dlm princess man & nice guy...patutnya writer polishkan karakter chae won ni..agak kecewa gak since i am huge fan of her acting...even avatar <---- jelir2 lidah ni milik mcw ni haha...
cuma aku leh nampak dia punya karakter byk bantu lead actor jek...a warm personality..
suka karakter dibawa chae won mase dia tgh mabuk...pastu mase terhuyung hayang smpt2 lagik marah neighbors..
pendapat aku, lakonan chae won ni dlm cerita ni adalah SUPERIOR...
she will be nominated in Best Actress category

Jo Sang Wook
mamat ni berjaya gak bwk watak yg serius, tp at the same time hv comical sense gak...
such a good leader, also a reliable "hyung"...natural acting
Lakonan adalah FAIR....
Nomination into BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR category.

Kim Hye Soo
aku rase budak ni pun punyai karakter yg bagus agak setanding lead actor/actress...
such good buddy to si on, lakonan pun agak fresh...
cuma boleh di'polish' di bhgn tertentu yg masih missing...
Lakonan adalah AVERAGE

Go Chang Suk
aku rasa dia ni comedian..
tgk dia ni berlakon sbg nurse laki pun dh rase kelakar...dlm bentuk bdn dia gempal tu, agak comey gak kadang2 haha
of coz he deserve the nomination...
Nomination into BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR category.

3. Aspek teknikal (Lakon layar, teknik pengarahan, sinematografi)   (7.2/10)

bg aku, aspek pengarahan agak biasa2 jek wlpn aku fhm diorg buat semuanya dlm studio shj..

operation mcm tak sgt "in detail" & kurang realistik terutamanya organ2 yg dibedah2...kdg2 nmpk cam orgn2 plastik...
forget about tht..
patutnya pengarah tmbh something about wht happened more in operation...
nak jadikan kita tersanga2 "tense"
wht i like iryu drama more, kita boleh rase emsoi masa doc tu buat pembedahan...
camne each one contribution in tht team memberikan 'kehidupan' kpd "patient" yg dibedah tu...

lain2...
aku suka screencap pengarah buat dlm epi 1...ngan pelbagai flashback scene yg menarik (camne si on boleh ade dream utk jadi pakar bedah yg berjaya..) ditambah ngan "tense" semasa si on baru turun keretapi, dia terus buat emergency operation kpd budak yg ditimpa kecelakaan cermin yg jatuh tetibe...
mmg a very good start...

Instrumentals pun best terutamanya yg ni..
agak mendamaikan dimainkan pada scene2 tertentu







4. Skor muzik (4/5)


Ranking tertinggi plg feveret...

1.


2.


3.




5. Kebarangkalian untuk tontonan semula (2.5/5)


--------------------------------------------------------------------------
(7.6+9.2+7.2+4+2.5 =7.63/10)
Nomination: Moon Jo Won, Moon Chae Won, Joo Sang Wook, Go Chang Suk

Last edited by dauswq on 13-10-2013 02:05 AM

Reply

Use magic Report

Follow Us
Post time 13-10-2013 09:00 AM | Show all posts
Kim Jong Kook - How come you don't know....ni pun salah satu track dalam OST good doctor


Last edited by violet_ingrid on 13-10-2013 09:02 AM

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 13-10-2013 11:13 AM | Show all posts
dah habis dah.....hehehe.....
tak follow so tak leh buat review
hehehe
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 16-10-2013 08:41 PM | Show all posts
nanti akn review citer nih..tgh tgk ....tp mcm terbyg2 cite medical top team jugak..sb genre sama
Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 16-10-2013 11:04 PM | Show all posts
juju_amin84 posted on 16-10-2013 08:41 PM
nanti akn review citer nih..tgh tgk ....tp mcm terbyg2 cite medical top team jugak..sb genre sama

terbayang2 kan ngan scene operation kt dlm medical top team?



Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 19-10-2013 01:05 PM | Show all posts
Joo Won ni mmg serbaboleh watak mcm2
kejap jahat kejap hero
skang autisme mmg mcm real selenga jekkk
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 21-10-2013 02:41 PM | Show all posts
mushroomsup posted on 19-10-2013 01:05 PM
Joo Won ni mmg serbaboleh watak mcm2
kejap jahat kejap hero
skang autisme mmg mcm real selenga jek ...

selenga.. hahaha.. tepat skali gmbaran tu..
selenga versi comey..


Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 22-10-2013 05:21 AM | Show all posts
mushroomsup posted on 19-10-2013 01:05 PM
Joo Won ni mmg serbaboleh watak mcm2
kejap jahat kejap hero
skang autisme mmg mcm real selenga jek ...

kan.. dia pandai pilih watak.. setiap watak yg dia ambik ada variasi.. memang versatile la.. bangga aku ada bias mcm ni.. hek hek..







btw, aku belum abis tengok lagi.. lepas abis kang aku review.. Last edited by manganini on 22-10-2013 05:27 AM

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 22-10-2013 07:00 PM | Show all posts
masuk nie da 3x loading nak tgk epi 19&20...
balik2 sangkut... dua2 epi dpt tgk suku awl, suku tgh, suku akhir...

bilelaa nak siap review kalau gini... blh ke calonkan je kategori pelakon terbaik tp xyah review?
Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 22-10-2013 07:04 PM | Show all posts
mitnick posted on 22-10-2013 07:00 PM
masuk nie da 3x loading nak tgk epi 19&20...
balik2 sangkut... dua2 epi dpt tgk suku awl, ...

tak leh...kena bg full review gak...

<--- avvy tu kang min hyuk ke?

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 22-10-2013 08:27 PM | Show all posts
dauswq posted on 22-10-2013 07:04 PM
tak leh...kena bg full review gak...

yelah2 nnt free2 iols try lagi..

cuma potong stim laa khenn bab peter pan tue xtgk lagi, tapi ending bab doc cameo PKW tue da tgk plk...

seolah2 xmkn nasik tapi perut kenyang

haah, avvy KMH nnt da bosan tuka lagi muka lain. nantikan mangsa seterusnyaa.. zass
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 28-10-2013 01:21 PM | Show all posts
aku nak komen gak pasal drama ni...
masa 1st episode, memang dasyatlah..smpai aku tak sabar2 nak cari online version...sebab kat korea dah awal 2 minggu.

Tapi story dier lemau skit...makin lama makin slow.. sayang sebab aku rasa watak shi on tu boleh di kembangkan lagi...maybe pengarah dier bukan yang superb kot...kalu nak lawan citer Brain tu...wpun hero tak hensem tapi aku rasa citer tu lagi padat....

anyway salute dengan Joo won, sebab bawak watak tu dengan superb. Sayang heroin tu punye watak macam tuh...chae won tu memang hebat...macam dalam citer innocent man tuh...tapi watak dier dalam citer nih, tak menonjolkan sapa dier yg sebenarnyer...mcm watak sampingan jer aku tgk....

Overall 7/10 - 7 tu pun sebab Joo Won berlakon best

Rate

1

View Rating Log

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 28-10-2013 07:42 PM | Show all posts
mitnick posted on 22-10-2013 08:27 PM
yelah2 nnt free2 iols try lagi..

cuma potong stim laa khenn bab peter pan tue xtgk lag ...

tengok je kat cenel KBS  391 tu.. kalau ada 392 tengok la 392..
malam ni  episode 19 ke kalau tak silap aku.. sikit lagi terlupa aku kat citer ni gara2 menengok lee minho dgn jung yonghwa..
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 28-10-2013 07:48 PM | Show all posts
sab_nyer posted on 28-10-2013 01:21 PM
aku nak komen gak pasal drama ni...
masa 1st episode, memang dasyatlah..smpai aku tak sabar2 nak ca ...

review sab lebih kurang sama dgn pendapat aku.. cuma aku tak tulis lagi reviewnya tapi isi2 penting dah set dlm otak dah.. haah bagi aku pun citer ni agak lemau skit.. kalau compare dgn brain, memang brain lagi mendebarkan walaupun heronya kertu...

medical top team tak tengok pulak sebab aku memang kureng sikit medical drama ni.. bosan kot sebab kerja pun dlm bidang yg lebih kurang sama..
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 28-10-2013 10:59 PM | Show all posts
manganini posted on 28-10-2013 07:42 PM
tengok je kat cenel KBS  391 tu.. kalau ada 392 tengok la 392..
malam ni  episode 19 ke kalau tak ...

mlm2 xsmpt tgk laa kaka... konsepnya iols nie memalam line xclear, bizi manjang
Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register

Points Rules

 

ADVERTISEMENT



 

ADVERTISEMENT


 


ADVERTISEMENT
Follow Us

ADVERTISEMENT


Mobile|Archiver|Mobile*default|About Us|CariDotMy

8-11-2024 09:46 PM GMT+8 , Processed in 0.416460 second(s), 28 queries , Gzip On, Redis On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

Copyright © 2001-2021, Tencent Cloud.

Quick Reply To Top Return to the list