kemasukan ke sekolah asrama penuh

mayyonnizz

i dah check...

my sis gagal lah.. ker sbp.. fuh bukan sennag dpt 5A pun belum tentu dpt lagi..

tp dah buat rayuan... & tgu keputusan MRSM plak..

nyway SBP dgn mRSM mana lag bagus ek?

HOTlips

Originally posted by macademia at 17-12-2007 11:07 AM
FYI sekolah agama ada 2 jenis..... 1. sekolah agama SBP, 2. sek agama bawah jabatan negeri.

Apa contoh sekolah agama SBP? Mcm mana apply? Through school as well ke? My nephew dpt sek agama di Sg Besar tp bukan SBP. Sekarang my sis tunggu MRSM plak. My bro inlaw pulak nak masukkan anak dia ke Maahad Tahfiz. Katanya di sini mcm sek agama SBP tp ada extra buat hafazan Quran. My bro inlaw dpt tahu dr cikgu tp dia x tahu detail kat mana. My hubby pun plan nak hantar our sons2 to this type of school. Katanya byk ada kat kelantan. Ada sape2 tau pasal ni? Kat mana ada sek yg jenis ni selain kelantan?

Yg me dgr those yg dah dpt tawaran SBP, memang x de lah MRSM. Tp MRSM pun bukan senang nak dpt coz terlalu ramai yg 5A.
Lagi satu, betul ke MRSM ni like private school sebab semua parents kena tanggung unlike SBP, such as text books, makan, asrama etc. Dulu my niece ada yg masuk MRSM tp since mak dia (my sis) keje MARA, so, everything was sponsored.

macademia

Originally posted by HOTlips at 17-12-2007 12:14 PM


Apa contoh sekolah agama SBP? Mcm mana apply? Through school as well ke? My nephew dpt sek agama di Sg Besar tp bukan SBP. Sekarang my sis tunggu MRSM plak. My bro inlaw pulak nak masukkan an ...

Dalam borang SBP, you need to decide, nak tick kotak "science" or kotak "agama". If you tick kotak "agama" meaning that your application would go to SBP aliran agama la. Eg SMAPersekutuan Labu.

FYI siapa kata SBP takyah bayar apa2? My girl masuk Form 1 early this yr, kena bayar food, asrama, dobi and books... all totalling more than 1K.

macademia

Originally posted by mayyonnizz at 17-12-2007 11:47 AM
i dah check...

my sis gagal lah.. ker sbp.. fuh bukan sennag dpt 5A pun belum tentu dpt lagi..

tp dah buat rayuan... & tgu keputusan MRSM plak..

nyway SBP dgn mRSM mana lag bagus ek?

YEla.... sekarang ni competition dasyat......

Mac from MRSM, so i understandla MRSM punya college life.

My girl yg tis yr Form 1, dia SBP. I was quite impressed with her school. Altho my fren kata, not all SBP is  as good as her school.

Having said tat, I would say, ada SBP yg elok, ada SBP yg not tat good. Ada MRSM yg elok and ada MRSM yg not tat good.....

Its just tat, SBP results can be known as early as Dec. MRSM nye results bulan Feb the next yr, so penantian yg panjang tu lagi memeningkan la.....

kikilalat

Originally posted by mayyonnizz at 17-12-2007 11:47 AM

nyway SBP dgn mRSM mana lag bagus ek?

tgk SBP maner and tgk MRSM maner la... so even if your sis dapat tawaran SBP or MRSM, kena tau jugak lah reputasi sekolah tuh... basically boleh monitor from their SRP and SPM results... then baru lah buat decision whether to terima the offer or not... if tak bley masuk masa form 1, can still get in masa form 4...

Masa time2 aku sekolah dulu... SBPs yg best untuk perempuan would be TKC, SSP, STF... yang best untuk boys MCKK, SAS... untuk coeds, Sekolah Sains Muar bcoz ambik excellent SRP students from all over Malaysia jer... MRSM yg best ialah MRSM Taiping.

Nowadays, kena rujuk balik rankings kementerian la... Biasa nyer the best boarding schools have the best teachers and education programme...

Iman_Baby

I dulu sekolah biasa je...high school... tapi sek me dulu.. mmg top dlm daerah Kluang.. kiranya budak2 situ semua selected gak.. yg tak dpt pi boarding school.. semua pi sana.. alhamdullilah, menjadi gak... hb pula sekolah SBP... so kami dua2 mmg ada pros n cons...

my doter.. dpt good result for her UPSR baru2 ni... tapi tak de plan nak hantar mana2 pun.. (infact tak mohon pun)... dia pun mmg tak moh pi.. n I pun mcm susah nak lepaskan...

my hb mmg encourage.. ialah.. dia pernah dok SBP... sure kata best.. lepas SPM je terus fly pi UK... Nani je yg berat hati nak lepaskan.. tengok le.. PMR nanti kot... masa tu rasa dia dah big enuf...

sebenarnya apa kelebihan duk SBP or MRSM ni.. my frens ckp... nanti kalau anak dpt good result masa SPM.. senang nak pi overC... sbb dah under MARA or Kementerian ... betul ke..

HOTlips

FYI siapa kata SBP takyah bayar apa2? My girl masuk Form 1 early this yr, kena bayar food, asrama, dobi and books... all totalling more than 1K.

Oh ye ke? Bulan2 bayar berapa lak?

tgk SBP maner and tgk MRSM maner la... so even if your sis dapat tawaran SBP or MRSM, kena tau jugak lah reputasi sekolah tuh...

Kemasukan ditentu/tetapkan oleh Kementerian kan? Maknanya ikut nasib/rezeki memasingla ye?
Btw, to me, kalau our kids ni dah memang ok dlm study mana2 sek pergi pun dia tetap boleh kan? Me, as a parent me memang berharap sgt my kids dpt masuk mana2 SBP/MRSM or mana2 sek berasrama. Sebabnya

macademia

Originally posted by HOTlips at 18-12-2007 08:23 AM

Oh ye ke? Bulan2 bayar berapa lak?



Kemasukan ditentu/tetapkan oleh Kementerian kan? Maknanya ikut nasib/rezeki memasingla ye?
Btw, to me, kalau our kids ni dah memang ok dlm study man ...

Bayar one shot masa pendaftaran Form 1. almost RM1300. TApi dengar ceta sapa tak mampu boleh buat 2-3 payments, and sapa yg layak ada potongan. Nak masuk Form 2 ni, tak tau la brapa kena bayar. Lesser kut.

In my case, I want all my kids masuk asrama. So, dapat SBP/MRSM kokak pun I accept. But then ofcourse I akan usahakan dapat a good one..... My kids dari kecik i dah brainwash.... masuk sek men, try to masuk asrama..... and they all pun okay and tak sabar2..... esp bila tgk kakak dia enjoy sakan bila masuk SBP tis year......

Tapi pada mac, if a child tak nak masuk.... jangan paksa..... tension gile nanti dia kat sana....

Iman_Baby

Originally posted by macademia at 18-12-2007 09:00 AM



Bayar one shot masa pendaftaran Form 1. almost RM1300. TApi dengar ceta sapa tak mampu boleh buat 2-3 payments, and sapa yg layak ada potongan. Nak masuk Form 2 ni, tak tau la brapa kena ba ...

a'ah btul tu mac.. my sister pun ckp.. masuk SBP sekarang pun banyak pakai duit.. bukan mcm zaman diorg dulu.. kalau kena bayar pun ciput je... tu yg dia ckap... ramai gak ibu bapa tolak.. sbb tak expect kena bayar byk tu...

my hb.. infact dah  brainwash my doter lama dah.... ckp best pi asrama.. makan ikut time.. petang2 boleh main game.. mcm2 le.. tapi rasanya dia mmg tak berminat kot... kena pula her mummy pun mcm tak bagi.. Kekadang kita blh nampak.. anak tu dah bersedia utk berdikari or not... dah boleh bawa diri... tang ni Nani tak nampak lagi dkt my doter... nampak je besar tapi childish lagi.. (i've 2 children.. both girl.. age 12 and 3 )...


sebenarnya.. nak pi asramakan... it's better masa form 1.. or form 4?

[ Last edited by  Iman_Baby at 19-12-2007 01:18 AM ]

kikilalat

Originally posted by Iman_Baby at 18-12-2007 12:05 AM
sebenarnya apa kelebihan duk SBP or MRSM ni.. my frens ckp... nanti kalau anak dpt good result masa SPM.. senang nak pi overC... sbb dah under MARA or Kementerian ... betul ke.....

Mebbe jugak... About 20% of my batch got into program yg pi oversea terus right after SPM... pi UK, US, Canada & Australia... Our batch got the best results in Malaysia (under Kementerian).

Satu lagik kelebihan if dapat sekolah SBP yg excellent nih, most of the questions yg the teachers hantar utk SRP & SPM to Kementerian (for exam questions pool) akan keluar in the actual exams... ;)

kikilalat

Originally posted by Iman_Baby at 18-12-2007 09:27 AM

sebenarnya.. nak pi asramakan... it's better masa form 1.. or form 4?...

My parents masukkan anak2 ke asrama, semua masa form 1... supaya nanti tak TERculture shock dengan budaya asrama...

My parents in law masukkan anak2 ke asrama, semua masa universiti ... sebab takut didikan kat asrama tak mencukupi...

lagipun my mil is a housewife... my parents both working...

mebbe, one of the factors masuk asrama or not ialah whether parents both working or not jugak kot...

another thing would be, how the parents disiplinkan anak2 jugak... my parents macam tak braper jer bab2 disiplinkan anak2 nih, so kasik cikgu disiplin kat asrama take over la ... my parents in law memang strict... tuh satu faktor jugak tuh

HOTlips

sebenarnya.. nak pi asramakan... it's better masa form 1.. or form 4?

better dr segi apa? Kalau dr segi persediaan mental tu mungkin la. Sebab form 4 dah besar. Dah lebih berdikari. Tp to me form 1 pun dah ok esp kalau boys. Mcm mana pun depends pd budak jugak la. Ada yg jenis x berdikari langsung. Ada jenis manja, anak emak lg x boleh berpisah. Nanti homesick pulak.
Me setuju dgn Mac. Tak leh paksa anak. Ikut kesediaan anak juga. Kita cuma boleh bg nasihat dan perangsang.

My nieces ada 2 org yg masuk MRSM. Yg sorang masa form 1 dan kakak dia masa form 4. Tp si kakak cuma bertahan beberapa bulan je. Tak boleh catch up dgn other students. Result periksa dia teruk. Kena tendang kalau x silap. At last balik ke sek biasa.

Satu lagik kelebihan if dapat sekolah SBP yg excellent nih, most of the questions yg the teachers hantar utk SRP & SPM to Kementerian (for exam questions pool) akan keluar in the actual exams...

Biasa jugak dgr cam ni. Tp me plak lebih suka kalau anak2 jawab soalan2 yg belum pernah dia tengok. Me respek kat budak2 yg still leh score byk A cam kat luar bandar tu. Dgn kemudahan yg kurang, tuition pun apa kata yg sekolah buat.
Sek my sis kat N9 (sek kg) Cuma 3 org je dpt 5A thn ni. Tp me respek tul budak2 yg 3 tu.
My nephew yg dpt 5A tu, gi tuition kat sekolah je. UPSRA dia dpt all As jugak. Tp dia memang ulat buku.

HOTlips

aku pun very strict tp anak jenis tak makan saman!   Tu pasal la me nak sgt depa masuk asrama. Biar org plak ajo!
Teringat aruah mak me cakap. Ada setengah budak memang jenis lebih mudah dgr cakap org.

Iman_Baby

Originally posted by HOTlips at 18-12-2007 10:28 AM

better dr segi apa? Kalau dr segi persediaan mental tu mungkin la. Sebab form 4 dah besar. Dah lebih berdikari. Tp to me form 1 pun dah ok esp kalau boys. Mcm mana pun depends pd budak jugak la ...

ni agaknya kategori anak me le.. manja n tak berdikari.... me pun mmg tak yakin nak lepaskan dia...

tapi mmg betul kat HOTlips... budak bdr kalau dpt 5A mmg tak heran sangat.. sbb dgn facility yg ada.. ditambah pula dgn effort yg parents letak.. tuisyen malam dkt sekolah, tuisyen setiap saturday, tuisyen dkt luar, home tuisyen lagi... kalau tak pdt 5A tak patut kot.. nanti bukan anak yg frust.. mak bapak yg frust menongeng..

mcm utk form 1 tahun ni... setakat hari ni yg kita dah pi book.. .. yg i dah kira2 utk kelas tuisyen dlm RM400 sebulan... itu belum masuk kelas2 lain.. dahsyat budak sekarang kan..

poison32

masa my bro last year dpt 5 A...sekolah dia yg hantarkan application...so we have to just wait for the offer letter..lagi satu kita tak leh nak choose the school

macademia

Originally posted by Iman_Baby at 19-12-2007 01:25 AM



ni agaknya kategori anak me le.. manja n tak berdikari.... me pun mmg tak yakin nak lepaskan dia...

tapi mmg betul kat HOTlips... budak bdr kalau dpt 5A mmg tak heran sangat.. sbb dgn f ...

yg bestnya, bila anak mac dah masuk asrama...... mac takyah pikir pasal tuition lagi...... hehe....