CariDotMy

 Forgot password?
 Register

ADVERTISEMENT

Author: Santeira

Between being a thinker and a simpleton?

[Copy link]
Post time 30-7-2008 09:08 AM | Show all posts
Freethought is a philosophical viewpoint that holds that beliefs should be formed on the basis of science and logic and should not be influenced by emotion, authority, tradition, or any dogma. The cognitive application of freethought is known as freethinking, and practitioners of freethought are known as freethinkers.

-wiki

anybody?

Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 30-7-2008 09:10 AM | Show all posts
Originally posted by Agul at 30-7-2008 09:08 AM
that's nice.


betul ke?
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 09:19 AM | Show all posts
Originally posted by Agul at 30-7-2008 09:06 AM
Yes. The world is adream. Thoughts are dream, thoughts are things. Therefore, we have toway. Think only of useful or beneficial  things. It will translate intouseful or beneficial action.


then a thinker will be a utilitarian huh?

tak begitu pendapat kebanyakan pemikir/pemerhati...

Ali Shariati tak berpendapat begitu... sebab pemikir ni mesti lebih jauh ke hadapan drp org biasa... jadi buah fikirannya boleh di guna untuk masa depan... yg sedar ia berguna
sejarah membuktikan hasil pemikiran pemikir tak begitu laku pada masa dia hidup.....

Abdulkarim Soroush pula kata yg intelektual tu adalah pemegang kuasa yg tak berkuasa... powerless weilder of power..
di sini:  
http://www.drsoroush.com/English/Interviews/E-INT-19990000-1.htm

so basically... pemikir kerja dia hanya berfikir dan lemparkan pendapat dia kepada khalayak... terima tak terima bukan soal dia...

[ Last edited by  petola at 30-7-2008 09:24 AM ]
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 09:25 AM | Show all posts
btw minta maaf pada tuan punya thread kalau thinker dalam posting2 saya bukan thinker yg dimaksudkannya..

:victory:
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 09:33 AM | Show all posts
apa pula kata pemikir Syed Hussein Alatas?

`How do the fools and bebalisma act to stifle the growth of the intellectual spirit? The fools block the development of the public demand for intellectual labour. The intellectuals do not have access to the means of creating a public demand for the results of their labour.

When an intellectual article is sent to the newspaper, the editor says that it is too heavy. Radio and television offer programmes which are non-intellectual. Speakers in forum are rarely intellectuals. Publishers publish ... rarely creative intellectual works. In the administration no credit is given for being an intellectual. Thus the public is not introduced to the products of intellectual labour...'


juga...


"..The modern educated man in many of the developing societies of Asia can develop into a specialist but not easily into an intellectual because being a specialist does not require a complete break with bebalisma.

It does not require conscious effort to probe into the entire foundation of one's outlook.

A man who specialises in dentistry, engineering, medicine, accountancy, or anything else can still harbour bebalian elements in his [or her] thinking..." (adoiiiiii....)


dari buku beliau 'The intellectuals and developing socities'.


bebalisma... hehe

[ Last edited by  petola at 30-7-2008 09:35 AM ]
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 09:35 AM | Show all posts

Balas #63 petola\ catat

then a thinker will be a utilitarian huh?
tak begitu pendapat kebanyakan pemikir/pemerhati...
err... a thinker thinks. may not be practical, or so, but at least a thinker thinks.
Reply

Use magic Report

Follow Us
Post time 30-7-2008 09:39 AM | Show all posts
Originally posted by Agul at 30-7-2008 09:35 AM
then a thinker will be a utilitarian huh?
tak begitu pendapat kebanyakan pemikir/pemerhati...
err... a thinker thinks. may not be practical, or so, but at least a thinker thinks.  


Ali ...



kalau seseorg pemikir terpaksa berfikir idea dia praktikal ke tak praktikal... then he will be a corrupted thinker..


kalau dia jadi ahli politik dia akan jadi politically corrupt thinker...
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 03:35 PM | Show all posts
simpleton - merely active

thinker - being creative
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 30-7-2008 04:57 PM | Show all posts
Originally posted by petola at 30-7-2008 09:39 AM



kalau seseorg pemikir terpaksa berfikir idea dia praktikal ke tak praktikal... then he will be a corrupted thinker..


kalau dia jadi ahli politik dia akan jadi politically corrupt牋...


Thinking is in the realm of doingness. you do, think.
No mater how much you think, you have to do.

It's not that hard to be a thinker. Every moment you 燼re thinking, you're a thinker. You don't have to think on extraordinary things to  燼n extraordinary degree.

So, a thinker  need not do anything, only think. He/she doesn't even need to take the philosophers pose.

If you think and stay quiet, you think. people will never know what you think about. They will never know you're a thinker.

If you do tell, you think, and tell. telling people what you think about doesn't detract you from being a thinker. Most people will know and燼pprove you for燽eing a thinker.

If you 'do', tell and think. You're still a thinker. Only you add doing and telling.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 04:59 PM | Show all posts

Balas #68 ajinomotonosuga\ catat

ok, that's a nice distinction.

Actually what is the standard definition agreed by most people on earth regarding a thinker anyway?

I think I don't use the std definition... my bad.

wiki?
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 05:09 PM | Show all posts
thinking basically ialah mencari sesuatu... betul tak?

apa yg kita cari?

kebenaran?
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 05:11 PM | Show all posts
i think therefore i am - rene descartes

Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 05:13 PM | Show all posts

Balas #71 petola\ catat

I think everyone actually want to find the same thing.
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 30-7-2008 09:01 PM | Show all posts
Originally posted by Agul at 30-7-2008 09:35 AM

The effect may come now, or way beyond other people understanding andconciousness that it will only be appreciated in the future.


there’s many a thinker who after death closes their eyes and opens ours...
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 31-7-2008 03:39 PM | Show all posts

hmm...

we human , is thinking all the time,  the act of thinking the  word "think" itself is actually a verb -  a perceptive type of verb to be exact. The act of thinking well, it can be consciously done though or vice versa.

Ur brain , my brain is thinking all the time. We cannot stop thinking.

That's why if u were to look at the central nervous system itself or the oraganization of the system , it is basically divided into autonomic nervous system, central and peripheral.

The "autonomic" ones is the automated, self regulated thinking part of the brain that controls all of our physiological function could never stop being "autonomously activated/ regulated - thus i woulds say thinking ...

then how about this  scenario

u went to McDonald. U saw the ad of vanilla milk shake and u think oh i love milk shakes and i would want ione coz in ur purse u have RM 50..so it is affordable. Then u realised as u paid the price, u said to urself

oh i better get a bottle of mineral water after this.....

and that very time

why suddenly the cognitive part of the brain "tells" u that  -- ok u need a bottle  of plain water ....



another scenario


why does a person in the cinema who really wanted to pass water but did not  well deliberately passing water  in the theater itself?

why does a person who eat plenty of SALTED peanuts would then be thinking of getting himself or herself a glass of plain water?


u see....ni dah thinking at cortical level + action...

the association between the first action will eventually lead to another event and this is due to the fact that the  thinking process is actually "on- going" . The brain learns . It makes an association - another learning process .


In those cases above, the brain knows the mechanism of the fluid regulation / retention etc and somehow affect the cognitive part ( conscious) part to execute the behavioral component so that we see a person would then started to buy  a bottle of mineral water or would find a toilet ....( if that person is not a baby or u know ....)
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 2-8-2008 11:34 PM | Show all posts
I have been skirting this thread for a while. Have this doubt as to what the thread owner really meant with the terms. Here and there some opinions do resonate with mine though.

IMO,  thinkers here are very special people who are able to espouse rationality in many aspects of human behaviour, thoughts and so on. Simpletons are mere fools lacking in good sense and judgement. But yes , they do think as in having thought processing but their end results may be just be acceptable or correct to them only.
Reply

Use magic Report


ADVERTISEMENT


Post time 2-8-2008 11:39 PM | Show all posts
Page o page?
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 3-8-2008 01:03 AM | Show all posts

Balas #76 hamizao\ catat

Sometime prominent thinker espouse highly erroneous thought. And people follow them.

Sometime the average people on the street may show wisdom but no one will listen.
Reply

Use magic Report

 Author| Post time 4-8-2008 05:32 PM | Show all posts

Balas #76 hamizao\ catat

Well, from my experience and observation, two types of idiosyncrasies--let's say between me and my sister--I think I am a thinker and I think she's a simpleton. Sometimes, I think being a thinker gives me advantage--that I have this ability to control myself from crumbling. Because I when I think, I seem to always try to find the root of the problem and it caused me temporary insomnia--made me unhappy.

So, because my sister (whom I assumed a simpleton) doesn't think as seriously as I am (which I also assumed). When she broke up with her boyfriend she cried and wallowed in self-pity. I just broke up with my boyfriend and I didn't cry--but I couldn't stop thinking. It caused me insomnia. So at the time I opened this thread, I wasn't able to sleep and I wished I could just cry my heart out the way she did and get okay afterwards--but I realized that I couldn't--which made me want to be a simpleton like her.

Just cry out--but I thought it would only amplify my disappointment. So I thought about how I am different from her and what made me an entirely different person.

But then Mr. Agul gives me a perspective--then I should just stop thinking.

And I did and I got to sleep again. Thanks for that.

[ Last edited by  Santeira at 4-8-2008 05:33 PM ]
Reply

Use magic Report

Post time 4-8-2008 05:39 PM | Show all posts

Reply #79 Santeira's post

and based on your statement a lady like me would think , hmm she broke up with someone and o okay her way of COPING with it is by "passing" [ another medical socilogy / psychology terminology / or ev health psychology  coping mechanism) well...another stimulus heheh to get me into thinking
Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register

Points Rules

 

ADVERTISEMENT



 

ADVERTISEMENT


 


ADVERTISEMENT
Follow Us

ADVERTISEMENT


Mobile|Archiver|Mobile*default|About Us|CariDotMy

31-1-2025 12:33 AM GMT+8 , Processed in 0.070891 second(s), 30 queries , Gzip On, Redis On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

Copyright © 2001-2021, Tencent Cloud.

Quick Reply To Top Return to the list