5 Sahabat Terlepas Hukuman Gantung Bunuh Remaja

CARI-MRO

GEORGE TOWN – Mahkamah Tinggi di sini, melepas dan membebaskan lima sahabat daripada pertuduhan membunuh seorang remaja lelaki, enam tahun lalu.


Kelima-lima tertuduh, S. Gopinath,32, J.Ragesuthan,24, S.Gokulan,24, V.Sharmah,24, dan K.Tatisan,24, dilepas dan dibebaskan selepas didakwa secara bersama membunuh dan mencederakan, T.Nhaveen.


Sebaik sahaja keputusan itu diumumkan oleh Hakim Radzi Hamid, suasana di dalam Mahkamah Tinggi bertukar hiba apabila terdapat ahli keluarga tertuduh menangis.

Foto: Kosmo

Hakim Radzi Hamid membuat keputusan melepas dan membebaskan kelima-lima tertuduh selepas mendapati pihak pendakwaan gagal membuktikan kes prima facie yang mengaitkan mereka dengan kes pembunuhan Nhaveen yang ketika itu berusia 18 tahun.


Dalam penghakimannya, Radzi berkata, mahkamah mendapati keterangan salah seorang saksi yang juga rakan mangsa, T.Previin tidak boleh dipercayai dan terdapat percanggahan dalam keterangan saksi.


“Apabila saksi tidak kredibel, keterangan saksi tidak dapat digunakan dalam tuduhan yang membabitkan tertuduh-tertuduh.


“Mahkamah mendapati tidak ada niat bersama tertuduh-tertuduh untuk mencederakan mangsa dan mendatangkan bencana tubuh ke atas mangsa.


“Oleh itu, mahkamah mendapati pihak pendakwaan gagal membuktikan kes prima facie terhadap tertuduh dan mahkamah melepas serta membebaskan kelima-lima tertuduh,” katanya ketika prosiding hari ini.


Menurut Radzi, walaupun terdapat bukti bahawa Nhaveen meninggal dunia akibat kecederaan termasuk trauma tumpul di kepala beberapa hari selepas kejadian itu namun tiada butiran jelas tentang apa yang berlaku pada hari tersebut.


Kelima-lima tertuduh telah dituduh membunuh Nhaveen, 18, antara pukul 11 malam dan tengah malam pada 9 Jun 2017, di Jalan Kaki Bukit, Bukit Gelugor.


Mereka didakwa mengikut Seksyen 302 Kanun Keseksaan yang dibaca bersama Seksyen 34 Kanun Keseksaan.


Selain itu, kesemua tertuduh juga didakwa mengikut Seksyen 326 Kanun Keseksaan iaitu mendatangkan kecederaan parah terhadap mangsa.


Pendakwaan dikendalikan Timbalan Pendakwa Raya, Mohd. Azhar Hamzah manakala Sharmah diwakili peguam Manveer Singh Dhilon, Peguam Datuk Naran Singh mewakili Gokulan, Gopinath dan Ragesuthen serta Tatisan diwakili peguam S.Yagoo. –CARI


Sumber: Kosmo

shamsadis

macam tu je, blood for blood takder?

kepompong

byk sgt alasan camni kat kes bunuh kat malaysia

kepompong

antara kita perasan/tahu dgn tak aje

lasagnaklcc

Ni yg katanya mangsa tu mcm lembut² sikit ke

Kesiannya mati tak dpt pembelaan. Tersenyum simpul memasing.

swateng1

power betul lawyer

Mooverine

Ni yang kena liwat dan bunuh masa beli burger tu kan..
kesian, meninggal macam tu saja la dia, tak ada pembelaan

krustykrab

So siapa pembunuh nya?

mizruncing

wahh makin berleluasa la nampaknyaaaa

Binodino

Janganla kawan mangsa tu tiba2 bunuh diri atau 5 ekor bangsat ni cari untuk balas dendam

lanacondor

Mooverine: Ni yang kena liwat dan bunuh m ...

kes mn u.. tepek sini.

limesherbet

Kes ape ni? so mreka betul bunuh ke tak?

Chah21

Vodooo... pastu sape yg bunuh? Xkn xde pelaku

mojarean_X

So pendakwaan x nk wat rayuan ke? Kes najib kemain korang habis-habisan ye

Skuau

takde niat??? tp 'melakukannya'??? apa maksud dan beza perkara ini???dan satu lg..awat guna istilah pembunuhan...sedangkan xde 'orng yg membunuh'??? Sapa pakar undang2...mohon penjelasan...

dani-rox

Dalam penghakimannya, Radzi berkata, mahkamah mendapati keterangan salah seorang saksi yang juga rakan mangsa, T.Previin tidak boleh dipercayai dan terdapat percanggahan dalam keterangan saksi.

Mungkin sbb saksi pun setengah mati kena pukul? Dihempuk di kepala dgn helmet. So ingatan agak lemah sebegitu.

Malaysia teen Nhaveen dies after brutal assault by bullies

GEORGE TOWN (The Star/Asia News Network) - An 18-year-old youth who was beaten with helmets, burned on his back and sodomised by an object by five youths following a spat has died.

The case comes hard on the heels of a shocking incident in Selangor in which navy cadet Zulfarhan Osman Zulkarnain, 21, was tortured and killed last week.

Student T. Nhaveen was found unconscious at around midnight last Saturday in a field next to Jalan Kaki Bukit in Bukit Gelugor.

He was buying burgers with his best friend T. Previin, 19, when two youths known to them started teasing the duo. Previin apparently tried to stand up for his friend but the duo were instead set upon by five youths.

Previin managed to escape with eye injuries by Nhaveen, who dreamt of becoming a composer, was beaten so badly he suffered internal bleeding in his head and abdomen. He was also sodomised and burnt on his back.

He died at 5.31pm on Thursday, days after he was pronounced brain dead. Police have arrested five suspects, aged between 16 and 18, over the attack and Nhaveen's death has been re-classified as murder.

Within an hour of T. Nhaveen's death, his friends and family members - both sad and angry - filled the ground floor of Penang Hospital's Block A.

More than 50 of them crowded the second floor hallway where he had been warded while many more packed the ground floor, spilling out of the entrance way onto the hospital grounds. A pall of grief hung over the area, the quiet occasionally pierced by bitter sobs.

Nhaveen's mother D. Shanti was beyond words and needed help to stay on her feet.

Women, Family and Community Development Minister Rohani Abdul Karim said on Friday she wants the five teenagers allegedly involved in the death of T. Nhaveen to be charged as adults.

"I urge for this case to be dealt under the Penal Code and not the Child Act," she told reporters outside the wake held for Nhaveen at the Batu Gantung funeral parlour on Friday.

Rohani teared up as she spoke, saying that she was a mother too.

"The one thing his mother asked me was this to be the last case and not let it happen to anyone else's child.

"She is a single mother and they were a close family," she said, adding that the family had been given emergency aid to help with funeral expenses.

Earlier, Rohani was seen consoling Nhaveen's mother D. Shanti, who urged for justice to be served.

"My son is dead. Don't let this happen to anyone else's child," she said through tears.

Nhaveen's funeral will be held at 2pm Friday at the Batu Gantung crematorium.

Section 97 of the Child Act 2001 states that a person cannot be sentenced to death for a crime they committed as a child, which is defined as anyone under the age of 18.

Under Section 302 of the Penal Code, however, a person found guilty of murder faces a mandatory death penalty.

The case was initially being investigated under Section 148 of the Penal Code for rioting with weapons.

T. Previin was wheeled out of the operating theatre after surgery to his right eye.

Previin's family could not bear to tell him that his best friend had died. His uncle, M.G.R. Devan, said Previin was still sedated.

"He is only half-conscious now so we will tell him later. My brother (Previin's father) made the decision not to tell him yet," said Devan.

One of the attackers had hit Previin in the face, possibly with a helmet, and fractured a bone just beneath his eye, leaving it fully bloodshot since the attack on June 10.

Nhaveen's uncle R. Thiyagarajan asked for some privacy for the family.

" Please give our family a moment. We were hoping for a miracle after all our prayers and candlelight vigil," he said in a voice thick with grief.

https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/se-asia/malaysia-teen-nhaveen-dies-after-brutal-assault-by-bullies


Kembalikan sistem juri

shy79

giler jahat..tp lepas mcm tu je..

mimi_ayu

Kesiannya kematian mangsa xdpt keadilan
Klu bkn tertuduj sape plak yg buat..xkan mangsa buat kt diri sendiri plak
Harap2 pendakwaraya buat rayuan..bkn main happy muka sorg2 tertuduh ya terlepas dr sabitan

kaedahnya

kesian mangsa, gitu je kena buli sampai meninggal

nazzse

Hakim mana bodoh bagi lepas ni