With so many different styles and fabrics to choose from, picking the best Unique Mens Underwear for you can quickly get confusing—not to mention overwhelming. So we talked to fashion and branding consultants, barbers, and stylists to get their take on the best underwear. They all agreed that briefs are the way to go, because they’re form-fitting and don’t ride up your thighs or add extra bulk when worn with slim pants.

For an affordable and well-made option, consider this seven-pair pack of ribbed cotton boxer briefs from Fruit of the Loom. They’re comfortable, breathable and surprisingly form-fitting—even after multiple washings. They also have a logo-free waistband to keep your underwear odor-free longer and are available in several colors.

British heritage label Derek Rose purveys luxury nightwear, lounge and underwear to royalty and celebrities alike. Its long-johns are modern in fit, streamlined for a flattering shape and made with the highest quality materials to ensure longevity. Hanro, a Swiss manufacturer, uses a similar minimalist approach to undergarment design and has a long catalog of classics, including this cotton sensation pair with a functional front fly.