Former bank officer loses suit against PTPTN

idril

Thursday May 31, 2012                                                                                Former bank officer loses suit against PTPTN                                        By QISHIN TARIQ
qishin.tariq@thestar.com.my                                                                                                                                    

                                                                                                                                                                          
  
KUALA LUMPUR: A former bank officer lost his suit against the National Higher Education Corpo­ration Fund (PTPTN) after the Sessions Court ruled that he had failed to prove that being in the fund’s blacklist was defamatory.
Mandeep Singh, 27, had filed the suit after he was detained by Immigration officers at LCCT in Sepang on July 6 as he was about to leave for a holiday in Guangzhao.

The officers detained him on the grounds that he was on the PTPTN blacklist.
Sessions judge Unaizah Mohd also ruled that Mandeep, 27, had failed to prove his claim that his detention by the Immigration officers was unlawful. The judge ordered that costs be paid to the defendants.
Mandeep said that had he won the suit, it would have set a precedent encouraging other students to step forward.
“That is why I will continue this legal action. This is not the end, I’ll take it to a higher court if necessary,” he told reporters.
Counsel Abdul Malik Hakim said his client would be filing an appeal to the High Court against the decision.
In Mandeep’s suit filed on Sept 20, 2011, he said he was unlawfully detained by Immigration officers at LCCT, who stopped him from going on his holiday in China.

His statement claimed that the PTPTN had damaged his reputation, making him look like a criminal by not removing his name from the Immigration Department’s blacklist.
He was put on the PTPTN blacklist in December 2010 when he fell behind on his arrears.

Mandeep claimed that he had asked the PTPTN to remove his name from the Immigration database after settling his outstanding student loan arrears on March 8, 2011, but it had failed to do so.

He had sought RM19,000 in special damages for the flight ticket and hotel booking as well as interest, costs and other relief deemed fit by the court.

baby_pingu

tapi dia dah clear arrears tuh on March kan? napa in JUly still ada nama dia blacklisted?

baghal_bortuqal

Thursday May 31, 2012                                                                                ...
idril Post at 31-5-2012 10:05

    dia dah bayar dan setel 8 march la... bukan dia yg gagal bayar.. PTPN tu yg gagal update senarai blacklist.


saman 190 jota je terus. bangang punya PTPN.

mallcop

Saman jangan tak saman! Hutang seciput cari, pegi cari hutang besar2 tu! Orang JPA & MARA yang tak bayar hutang apa citer? Gi bayar, kang dalam kubur sahabat2 tanya sambil menhempas & baling tau! (Nasib baik aku tak hutang time belajor!)

fredbok87

haha..padan muka ptptn.... saman jerk.....

tungkai

Ni bukan dia tak nak bayar. Dia dah bayar tp nama dia still black list lg..Aku rasa Mandeep ni tak followup ngan PTPTN kot. Mcm member aku dulu tiap2 minggu kasi gegar PTPTN ni. Tak gegar memang tak jalan...

nalis

lepas buat setllement ngan PTPTN tu dia tak check balik senarai blacklist kat imigresen ke?

idril

dia dah bayar dan setel 8 march la... bukan dia yg gagal bayar.. PTPN tu yg gagal update s ...
baghal_bortuqal Post at 31-5-2012 10:09

it had failed to do so to refer to ptptn la kan ek.... kalau camtuh memang patut la kena saman ptptn tuh... then, asal court judge tuh  denied dia nyer claim?

brown_pupil

Heran aku.. kalau dia betul dah settle hutang ngan ptptn, xkan xde black & white.. a.k.a surat pelepasan? Aku masa bayar dulu dpt je surat pelepasan dari black list on the spot. Imigresen clear dlm 1 hari jer.. I smell something fishy.. ntah2 kata bayar, tapi x habis and still ada outstanding. Pastu berangan nak berholiday kat oversea kekdahnya..

idril

Heran aku.. kalau dia betul dah settle hutang ngan ptptn, xkan xde black & white.. a.k.a surat pelep ...
brown_pupil Post at 31-5-2012 10:19

    mungkin jugak.... dia yg claim kata bayar outstanding.. tapi dia kena tengok berapa outstanding tuh... kena bayar lump sum outstanding tu baru nama boleh clear..... member aku cepat jer ptptpn clear kan nama....

R2D2

PTPTN, Courts Mammoth, ASTRO dll sama je..kalau dh byr memang lambat update. Info dari kekawan..

mallcop

Ni bukan dia tak nak bayar. Dia dah bayar tp nama dia still black list lg..Aku rasa Mandeep ni tak f ...
tungkai Post at 31-5-2012 10:14

    habis tu pesal saman dia gagal! takkan hakim berat sebelah...kut!

brown_pupil

Dia ingat, bayar balik bulan2 mcm dia selalu bayar tu cukup kot.. maybe dia ni buat2 lupa yg kalau nama dah masuk blacklist ptptn, nak clear nama tu kenalah bayar balik semua hutang2 tu. Yang aku heran gak, xkan dia xde call ptptn to confirm nama dia dah clear ke belum..

Unless la kalau dia dah follow up dgn ptptn, confirm dgn imegresen nama dia dah clear tapi bila nak berlepas kena tahan.. then it will be a strong case utk dia saman ptptn dgn imigresen..

baghal_bortuqal

it had failed to do so to refer to ptptn la kan ek.... kalau camtuh memang patut la kena saman p ...
idril Post at 31-5-2012 10:16

mungkin hakim buang saman dia pasal isu nama blacklist ni "defamation" atau tidak. pertimbangan penghakiman bukan pasal setel ke tak.

tak tahu pertimbangan penghakiman hakim cemane.. mintak loaya2 ulas.

nalis

Heran aku.. kalau dia betul dah settle hutang ngan ptptn, xkan xde black & white.. a.k.a surat pelepasan? Aku masa bayar dulu dpt je surat pelepasan dari black list on the spot. Imigresen clear dlm 1 hari jer.. I smell something fishy.. ntah2 kata bayar, tapi x habis and still ada outstanding. Pastu berangan nak berholiday kat oversea kekdahnya..
brown_pupil Post at 31-5-2012 10:19

Kan? Bini aku pun dapat clear blacklist tu sehari je

bronok

bayar outstanding berangan macam bayar habis

kudajantan77

Pi Ti Pi Ti Pu ...

si bulat

adik bulat kena kes yg same baru2 ni... last month kalau x salah...
dia nk gi overseas, suddenly kena sekat sebab ptptn still blacklisted...
sedangkan dia dh buat full settlement last 2 years...
pas tu the best thing is beg2 dia semua dh lepas naik flight... dia je yg x lepas...

pas tu kitorg gi ptptn the next day nye..
ptptn kate dlm sistem diorg dh lame dh clear...
diorg salahkan sistem imigresen...

pas tu siap officer tu bgtau, ade amount to be refunded lagi sebab bayar habis...
around 2K ++... byk tu... tp ptptn ni diorg senyapkan je pasal refund tu...
yg tu tugas peminjam lak kena gi check tgk ade refund ke tak & so on...

patutnye ptptn hantar lah surat maklumkan pasal ni...
& diorg patutnye hantar updated data ke imigresen...
jgn nk main salahkan imigresen then imig salahkan ptptn sebab x update...
bende jadik 2 thn lepas la... takkan x leh nk settle kan lagi...

staff ptptn punye la ramai...
mase bulat dok tunggu adik settlekan tu, sempat le memerhati staff2 diorg ni keluar masuk ofis... dh le pakai selipar je.. pas tu siap ade yg bawak makanan tapau lagi pulak...
mase tu lebih kurang kul 10 am.... breakfast time dh lame habis tu...
mane ade dh makan time kul 10 am tu...
dh lame dh govt hapuskan rules tu...

so, bulat rase sape yg kena tu patutnye berkumpul & buat saman beramai2...
sebab kena bagi kesedaran sikit sebab bende ni melibatkan duit org, maruah org bagai...
kena sekat dgn imigresen tu as like a criminal pulak..
org kalau tgk diorg mase tu mesti ingat kes ape ke.. dadah ke ape ke...

lagi satu cube bayangkan kalau ade kes emergency ke nk kena pegi overseas gak mase tu, camane?

renung2 kan lahhh....

baghal_bortuqal

adik bulat kena kes yg same baru2 ni... last month kalau x salah...
dia nk gi overseas, suddenly ke ...
si bulat Post at 31-5-2012 10:39

    classic case.

apa2 senarai blacklist: masuk cepat, keluar lambat.

apa punya hamjadah. bangang tol.

tungkai

Reply 12# mallcop

Sessions judge Unaizah Mohd also ruled that Mandeep, 27, had failed to prove his claim that his detention by the Immigration officers was unlawful. The judge ordered that costs be paid to the defendants.

Aku rasa mamat ni terhina sbb kena tahan kat airport seolah2 mcm dia ni criminal. Malu dan burn semua duit nak melancong kat China. Dia tak tau bukan dia sorang je kena camtu padahal ramai lagi kena. Tak silap aku memang PTPTN ada bg tau psl x boleh keluar Malaysia kalau ada outstanding hutang kan..??