CariDotMy

 Forgot password?
 Register

ADVERTISEMENT

View: 141|Reply: 0

Jesus sujud: Islam vs kristian

[Copy link]
Post time 23-12-2025 05:48 PM | Show all posts |Read mode
Edited by ibnur at 23-12-2025 05:49 PM

https://x.com/CedarsAndSaints/status/2003151517755621604

Post dari @CedarsAndSaints (aka Cedars and Saints), seorang Kristian Lebanon yang aktif promote Kristian Timur. Dia tunjuk ayat Bible Matthew 26:39 – Jesus "fell on his face and prayed" di Taman Getsemani – dan claim Muslim salah sangka, sebab Jesus buat sujud 600 tahun sebelum Islam wujud, jadi "Islam yang copy Christ", bukan sebaliknya.

Fakta sebenar: Sujud (prostration) memang ada dalam Bible (Jesus, nabi-nabi seperti Moses, Abraham, dll.), dan juga tradisi Kristian awal/Timur (contoh Maronite monks masih buat).

Tapi cara solat Muslim (sujud + rukun lain) lebih terstruktur ikut Quran. Tak ada bukti langsung Islam "copy" spesifik dari Kristian; sujud adalah amalan semitik kuno untuk tanda hormat/taat kepada Tuhan, warisan bersama dari tradisi Abrahamik (Yahudi, Kristian, Islam).

Claim "siapa copy siapa" ni lebih kepada debat polemik, bukan fakta sejarah mutlak. Kedua-dua pihak guna ayat sama untuk justify amalan masing-masing.
Reply

Use magic Report

You have to log in before you can reply Login | Register

Points Rules

 

ADVERTISEMENT


Forum Hot Topic
Quiz : Personality Test [Who is the biggest fool?]
gekkouQuiz : Personality Test [Who is the bigg
Views : 5741 Replies : 28
Orang Inggeris Takut Hilang Di Dunia. Takkan Inggeris Hilang Di Dunia.
B40tastePoshOrang Inggeris Takut Hilang Di Dunia. Ta
Views : 2297 Replies : 19
Brother Kat Threads Ni Heboh Pasal Bau "Bunga Orked" Rakan Ofis
tumpanglalu74Brother Kat Threads Ni Heboh Pasal Bau
Views : 2559 Replies : 69
"Ku Sangkakan Dua, Rupanya Tiga"  - Isteri Ketiga Bekas Panglima Darat Muncul Dengan Bisul Kronik
Mahathirina"Ku Sangkakan Dua, Rupanya Tiga" - Iste
Views : 59283 Replies : 35
travel to chicago
kukukud56travel to chicago
Views : 3536 Replies : 0
Langsung tak ada job, Daí Syed spend time dengan anak bini je-hanya terima watak ustaz je
RalineLangsung tak ada job, Daí Syed spend ti
Views : 25303 Replies : 101
TRAVEL WITH GOJO
saturo1gojoTRAVEL WITH GOJO
Views : 4143 Replies : 0
SATURO GOJO TRAVEL
saturo1gojoSATURO GOJO TRAVEL
Views : 4245 Replies : 0
best  airlines services
kukukud456ydDdbest airlines services
Views : 4344 Replies : 0
TRAVEL WITH GOJO
gojo2344TRAVEL WITH GOJO
Views : 4950 Replies : 0

 

ADVERTISEMENT


 


ADVERTISEMENT
Follow Us

ADVERTISEMENT


Mobile|Archiver|Mobile*default|About Us|CariDotMy

24-1-2026 03:19 AM GMT+8 , Processed in 0.043348 second(s), 15 queries , Gzip On, Redis On.

Powered by Discuz! X3.4

Copyright © 2001-2021, Tencent Cloud.

Quick Reply To Top Return to the list