|
|
Perbandingan finale OIAM Vs AF (apa kata anda?)
[Copy link]
|
|
|
AF7 seperti peribahasa...rumah siap...pahat masih berbunyi...
yg nyata...AF7 tidak sehebat dulu...
af musim 1-3 mungkin still bgs, sbb the one n only singing reality show...
tp, bila byk reality show yg tumbuh bgai cendawan...af kena buat sesuatu untuk kekal terbaik...
bg sy, bahang dan memori oiam3...masih terasa...
rasa tak seronok tnpa konsert2 dr oiam3...
even, ada mentor...
sy asik membandingkan peserta2 mentor dgn peserta oiam3... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
af gada2x...
publisiti peserta mlebihi bakat....
oiam mencri bakat .....
peserta oiam dberi tugasan mencabar.... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
OIAM da besh!!!!
AF cam petandingan karoke jeh aq rase..
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
lagi best tengok OIAM |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
rasanyer af dah xrelevan..better stop dlu.. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
of course OIAM3 lebih bagus drpd AF7..
-peserta OIAM lebih berdikari berbanding AF,kene pandai wat arrangement sendiri..
-komen pengkritik OIAM lebih telus,jujur berbanding AF..macam bias je..
-pemuzik dalam OIAM lebih hebat berbanding AF
-peserta2 OIAM lebih survive berbanding perserta AF..(pelik bile pengkritik AF cakap aril tu survival..)
satu perkara lagi i tak gemar pasal AF nie,ape motifnye diorg kurung pelajar sampai camtu skali??tak dibenarkan tengok dunia luar..takleh berhubungan ngan keluarga..ape hasilnye??bagus sangat ke??
disebabkan diorg tak tengok dunia luar la diorg pasan bagus..tak tau feed back drpd org luar..
kalau budak2 OIAM,diorg sentiasa dapat perbaiki diri sebab terima macam2 komen drpd org luar..kalau dah jadi artis pon kene byk bercampur ngan org ramai,bukan dok dalam banglo je nyanyi dan menari sendiri.. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
no comment la sebab x follow OIAM...
tp final concert af agak bosan la... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Balas #52 ain_lazerella\ catat
betul tu ain, rasanya selingan lawak2x bodo n gimik2x murahan tu x payahla diadakan lagi..dah macam konsert kat funfair jer...lepas 7 musim asyik ulang benda yg sama..boleh muntah darah jadinya... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Balas #53 esprito193\ catat
kan???
ya ampunnn..memang mengantuk laa..
org2 yg tengok kat stadium pon boleh ngantuk,ni kan pulak org yg tengok kat umah.. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ak rsa sma je...yg pnting usaha diorg slps ni....kalu x usaha smua x kmana.... |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
AF7??? pleaseeeeeeeeeeeeee 
1st time aku dengar lagu bebudak nie kat hot FM this morning..makk aiiii ..OUT!!!! suara hancuss..pitching x sampai.. sakit telinga jek..trus tukar radio lain |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Budak tadika pun tahu yg kualiti OIAM neh jauh lebih tinggi dari AF.....
About the Finals.....
There's a reason why they call the OIAM finals, The Grand Finals because it was a really, truly GRAND event.....
OIAM 3 Grand Finals out classed AF7 Final Concert in every way you can think of;
1. The finalists - OIAM's are in a class of their own. All three of them are great. And they performed great. I'm not bias. I was not impressed by the performance of the AF finalist. They are just yawn worthy for me.
2. The stage - magnificent stage for OIAM if compared to the red horn AF7 Finals stage. AF7 just looks so high and empty. And what makes it even worse is that the students just did not know how to utilise it.
3. Lighting - Brilliant for OIAM and just plain mediocre for AF. Lighting is important to live up the mood of any event.
4. Sound system - Excellent sound system/engineering for OIAM. The music and the voice of the finalists blended well. AF on the other hand, I could not hear the finalists voice clearly.
5. The host - Awal & Marion performed their job excellently. PROFESSIONALISM! No stupid jokes. They know their boundary. They didn't waste time, whereas AF7 host just dwell on stupid things and grilled the students with idiotic questions. Time was wasted, everyone was getting sleepy. People do not want to hear lame jokes. People just want to hear the finalists perform their songs. One word to describe the host - BRAINLESS IDIOT!!!!
6. The judge/jury - OIAM timed the judge comments well and the judges know how to give a straight to the point and honest comment whereas the AF jurists just dwell and dwell and dwell on the same thing over and over and over again. Gosh, the event could finish at 11.30 if they just could keep it short and simple!
7. The dress/clothing - Should I even state the obvious! It's the finals! Give the AF students some nice decent suits for one of their songs. Aweera and Tomok were simply elegent that night! Admittedly Esther's dresses were crappy but at least the crap is even better than Isma's pajama's dress.
8. Song choice and music arrangement - OIAM is way way better. It's a given that OIAM finalists can choose their own songs, but AF team too could choose good songs for the students. But no, they chose to give students crap! Thus the end results were crap too. And the new songs for the AF student? What were they thinking. I could not digest it well. The new songs for OIAM finalists were great.
9. The drama - OIAM had its short drama where Tomok was supposed to be eliminated, and that's just it. AF had too many drama. The idiotic host with the stupid questions. The endless jury comments. The uncivilised performance by one of the contestants (WTH was he thinking - he's a monkey or something?)
10. The winner - Just like what Paul Moss said, a class performance by Tomok. Hafiz's was just flat out uninteresting. I know he did try hard and I saw his great P. Ramlee's and R. Kelly's cover, but his performance for the finals was just 'huh?' I believe it could be attributed to the lame song choice, lame dress/clothing, lame chareography. Gosh, were the AF team trying to sabotage this kid? I really pity him.
11. The timing - OIAM was timed well. But AF was dragging.
The above are just some of the things where OIAM 3 Grand Finals outclassed the AF7 Finals.
I hope that the OIAM team could maintain this good job of theirs for OIAM 4 (if any).
And if there is going to be any AF8 (i wish they could just bury the show now), they should learn something from the OIAm team on how to make a great show.
[ Last edited by defeduck at 19-5-2009 08:49 ] |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
Post time 18-5-2009 06:55 PM
Author
