Doownloaders... Beware

bluesuntukaku2k

berbaloi dengan bayar sewa bulanannya....

artgeex

korang, adik aku cakap, kat US yang bapak segala downloading ni pun takde implementation camni

so logik ke tak logik, kalau negara Malaysia, yang mostly orang tak tau pun lagi nak guna operating system dengan betul (no offense) nak implement benda yang complicated macam ni

inform me if i am wrong, tapi memang tak pernah la pulak aku dengar negara US or even India (yang terer bab programming) yang limitkan usersnya download stuff dari internet, legal or illegally.

what say you?

DanaScully

dah ada ke yg kena tangkap?

oobi

Originally posted by artgeex at 8-12-2007 06:23 PM
korang, adik aku cakap, kat US yang bapak segala downloading ni pun takde implementation camni

so logik ke tak logik, kalau negara Malaysia, yang mostly orang tak tau pun lagi nak guna operati ...

actually, they have already implemented this in US. not by government, but self initiative by ISPs. not sure if your adik read recent lawsuit by comcast users. comcast track down users with heavy download activities and limit/delay their traffics, and users take comcast to US court for misleading them (comcast should have advised them when they got the service, in end users service agreement).

right now, music industry is the only industry that really goes hard finding illegal music downloaders and several thousand downloaders had been sued, including college students (downloading using college network). none of these are initiated by the government and of course music industry gets cooperation from ISPs. film and sofware industries have started to do the same too.

iamsairul

hmmm...xpatut xpatut...ni mesti kes byk cd lagu xlaku nih...

MulutBecok

owwwhh that's hurt

oobi

yep! and deep into the pocket. in 2003, a 12 years old was sued and settled for $2000 for illegal mp3 download with RIAA. summer this year, RIAA (Recording Industry Association of America) sued 15 university of georgia students for illegal downloading. this month alone, RIAA got 32 vanderbilt students (23 have been identified), while last year they got 20 for the whole year from U of Vanderbilt.

RIAA Pre- Lawsuit Letters Go To 22 Campuses In New Wave oF Deterrence Program

so, it's not hard to trace down illegal activities and they don't have to stop by each house. if they can do it in north america, malaysia is nothing. so, be careful (malaysia probably under pressure from US to do this)

artgeex

argh! so it can be done lah?

matilah kalau tak boleh download mp3 segala ni

artgeex

damn. jadi betul lah benda ni realiti bukan fantasi tmnut :@

lets just hope yang implementation ni sekadar hangat-hangat tahi manuk saje

bluesuntukaku2k

camna nak jadi dunia tanpa sempadan...........

ninja9

ayoyo...kalau implement senang sangat dorang kesan sapa yang kuat download..

kalau ada yang kena tangkap dan kena denda 500,000 ... korang berhenti mendownload ker...

MulutBecok

Originally posted by oobi at 9-12-2007 07:57 AM

yep! and deep into the pocket. in 2003, a 12 years old was sued and settled for $2000 for illegal mp3 download with RIAA. summer this year, RIAA (Recording Industry Association of America) sued ...

erkkk seriously kalau Malaysia betul2 implement bende ni
broadband is nothing
ye la kalau setakat nak surfing biasa2 tak perlu sampai I Mbps ni
but perhaps benda ni just hangat2 taik ayam je sebab baru habis seminar kan...

oobi

Originally posted by MulutBecok at 17-12-2007 01:52 AM

erkkk seriously kalau Malaysia betul2 implement bende ni
broadband is nothing
ye la kalau setakat nak surfing biasa2 tak perlu sampai I Mbps ni
but perhaps benda ni just hangat2 taik aya ...

they implement this in us and people still seek for better broadband speed. we have to look at big picture instead of what we do right now. downloading is a big word, and can be done legally and/or legally. it's really a choice.

if they implemented this in malaysia, they will find a way to keep their broadband customers.

p/s: people always find a way to break the law. macam dadah, hukuman mengedar dadah di malaysia adalah gantung sampai mati (for 100g and over or something) and yet, people still do it.

MulutBecok

yerpp..i have to agree with you
mungkin masa depan, when we have a decent speed
all the DVD can just be download, instead buying it kat kedai
satu kemudahan yang baik
just nak tau DVD kat US sekeping dia jual berapa?
mesti murah kan?
coz my friend kat sana apa2 jua dvd baru dia mesti beli
sy suruh dia download tapi dia takut..dia kata skang CIA tengah hebat menggempur downloader2 haram ni
kalau murah okla..ni kalau sampai beratus2 sekeping, sapa yang mampu (but i know this is just an excuse mereka2 yang tak mau keluarkan duit untuk beli barangan berkualiti )

[ Last edited by  MulutBecok at 17-12-2007 07:32 AM ]

oobi

dvd kat sini memang murah. retail price biasanya dalam US$25. depends pada cerita juga. kalau sales, boleh dapat dalam less than US$15. tapi kat sini, sales tax count masa beli (not included in the price, tak macam kat malaysia), but masih murah.

0001

Yup...it can be done... but... ahah... there's a but here...

Will tmnut/isps want to spend all that money to track down illegal downloaders... AND... worse... risk losing users?

Kalau diaorang cap download limit ramai orang, apa kata kita semua amik sekor lawyer, then sue balik diaorang longgok2 duit... pastu kita takyah download mp3 lagi... dah cukup duit nak beli yg ori nyer.

fly_in_d_sky

Originally posted by 0001 at 17-12-07 08:41 AM
Yup...it can be done... but... ahah... there's a but here...

Will tmnut/isps want to spend all that money to track down illegal downloaders... AND... worse... risk losing users?

Kalau di ...

cukup ke duit tu utk cover downloader2 kat msia nanti?
hehehe ......

jimbait

Bapak dier...Rm250,000
maner nak carik duit...kopak aku...

jimbait

Aku rasa derang x kan buat pasal kalau dier laksanakan,lingkup la streamyx...
speed laju giler tp tuk check email,chatting,forum..buat aper!!
kalau seblom ni diorang throttle torrent,satu penyeksaan,tp sib baik ader alternatives...
lepas block torrent,block outlook express pulak...alahai...ahh dulik la...bukan aku guna pun...
tp ni diorang nak sue org yg download ilegal materials....
Boley dikira la berapa percent jer yg hanya download legal files..75% files kat internet adalah ilegal!!(aku rasa kot)...