lagu avril lavigne girlfriend tu ciplak ke?

eddysheddy

ari tu baca sok kabar kata ada org dakwa lagu girlfriend tu lagi ciplak lagu dulu2.. betul ke? sape penah dgr lagu dulu tu.. sama ke?

kalau dah ada topic ni merge jelah ye.. tetinggal ketapi aku ni..

alone_inluv

ade dgar jugak psal bende nie..
rentak die cm 1 lgu yg femes gak r..tp xigt tjok..
lirik die pon cm ciplak lgu I wanna be ur boyfriend-The Rubinoos..

eddysheddy

Originally posted by alone_inluv at 21-7-2007 09:35 PM
ade dgar jugak psal bende nie..
rentak die cm 1 lgu yg femes gak r..tp xigt tjok..
lirik die pon cm ciplak lgu I wanna be ur boyfriend-The Rubinoos..

thanks alone kerana reply

iloveyou

lebeyh kurg sme jew bler dgr lgu yg asl..
btw avril sedia t0 court klu d0rg xpueh ati..

opocot

lagu tu mmg dia ciplak la ek? sbb mmg exactly sebijik rentak dia.. cuma lirik jek ubah.. tu pun tang boyfriend - girlfriend

narelle

yer ke ciplak? stakat satu line jer yg nk sama..
and rentak dier sooooo diff.
and IF dia ciplak ponn...
avril made it soooo much betta

alone_inluv

Originally posted by eddysheddy at 22-7-2007 02:50 PM

thanks alone kerana reply

same..

narvmarishka

Originally posted by alone_inluv at 21-7-2007 03:35 AM
ade dgar jugak psal bende nie..
rentak die cm 1 lgu yg femes gak r..tp xigt tjok..
lirik die pon cm ciplak lgu I wanna be ur boyfriend-The Rubinoos..

tak silap rentak lagu ni sama cam rentak lagu Toni Basil-Hey Mickey...;)

alone_inluv

Originally posted by narvmarishka at 23-7-2007 06:16 PM


tak silap rentak lagu ni sama cam rentak lagu Toni Basil-Hey Mickey...;)

ye kot..
aku nyayi2 cm same je..

0077

aku dah dgr. mcm hampir sama je.

gjoy_chester

sampling menyampling  ni memang biase kat US nun...

biar la ciplak ke plagiat ke..yang penting jadinye sedap..

shidan76

ambik dari wikipedia

"Girlfriend" was the subject of a lawsuit filed by songwriters for The Rubinoos,
who alleged that the writers of the song plagiarised The Rubinoos' single "I
Wanna Be Your Boyfriend". Reviewers have noted that the chorus bears a
resemblance to The Rubinoos' 1979 single "I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend", in
which they sing "Hey hey, you you, I wanna be your boyfriend" similar to
"Hey hey, you you, I want to be your girlfriend" in "Girlfriend". The song can
be heard on the Rubinoos' MySpace page.
On May 25, 2007, Lavigne, her songwriter Lukasz Gottwald, her record label,
and Apple Inc. were sued by James Gangwer and Tommy Dunbar, songwriters
for The Rubinoos, over claims that "Girlfriend" infringes their copyright on their
1979 song "I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend". Lavigne's manager, Terry McBride,
denied that "Girlfriend" was copied from "I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend", and
pointed out that "Boyfriend" itself is similar to The Rolling Stones' "Get off of My
Cloud". McBride said he hired a musicologist to compare the songs; according to
McBride the musicologist reported that the songs were totally dissimilar, even a
different meter. Prominent music critics such as Stephen Thomas Erlewine of All
Music Guide have publicly noted that the song is a "total lift from the Rubinoos"
song. McBride said that Lavigne has no current plans to settle the case, but will
consider the costs of defending the case against those of settling.
Critics have compared the middle section of the song with the bridge from Toni
Basil's "Mickey".

lilymaylily

musicologist? first time hearing that!

shidan76

musicologist is a noun for musicology and it means "The historical and scientific
study of music"